Among a few really good friends in Afghanistan, I had a particularly interesting and colorful friend who was in the Navy at the time. Navy?! In a landlocked country? Don’t draw that Editorial Page cartoon just yet―it was actually a good move by the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs to help with manpower. It was becoming important to lengthen the time between deployments for Soldiers who were being sent on too many rotations to reasonably sustain a family life. This Navy piece was feasible since so many in the military are in professions that cross over to any big military endeavor: medical, administrative, logistics, etc.
This guy worked in my Operations cell and was a First Lieutenant at the time while I was a Major but, really, we were equals in our dedication to the cause and the smarts and energy we were willing and able to devote to it. Also, we were just outright friends, sincerely, and got along really, really well.
Not that it mattered, but I found out early on that he was quite a blue-blood. He had an historically recognizable last name. He told me about it. His Ivy-league grandfather was a Cabinet-level multi-Presidential advisor and a huge player in most of the big decisions of World War II and beyond. Grandfather eventually became chairman of the World Bank, Chairman of Chase Manhattan Bank, Chairman of the Ford Foundation, and more―Jesus Christ! Slow down, Mister Grandpa!
My friend was justifiably very proud of his grandfather and he himself had attended the most prestigious private High School I know of and was an Ivy-league business school graduate and, after he got to know me, mentioned that he wanted to get me into his business with him on Wall Street. He was interesting in other ways too; he was a great runner and he’d founded a charity of marathon running to raise money for pediatrics (once running a marathon in Antarctica!), and he was into a lot of natural health foods. We’d sometimes work out together and he, though thin, was a workout animal. I was in great shape for my age but I had a hard time keeping up with him. We’d climb these big walls of ‘Hesco’ barriers carrying big plate-weights from the gym with us, struggling to push the weights up each level, then climbing up after and lowering them down. Up and down, up and down. Laughing and cursing.
One time, we both stayed up all night writing a fantastic proposal together to get funding for a huge road to aid in the flow of agricultural resources to marketplaces. It was accepted.
Another cool thing about him (I promise I’ll stop soon!): he always wanted to be on a convoy combat patrol even though all Navy guys were exempt and (legally) even precluded from such patrols. Because he was on a patrol that had enemy contact early on in the tour, he came to my attention when the big boss moved him into my Operations cell ostensibly as punishment for having got himself into that situation. He was no longer in a position where he could sneak himself onto a combat patrol without everybody knowing.
I’d always had an adventurous life too, and we’d trade stories. I think he was impressed with the walls I’d climbed over to be where I was; there was a mutual respect. Also, he was one of the few people at that Officer level who held a lot of my centrist and liberal views and so we connected on that level too.
The only uncool thing I remember is when he was asked by his father to write an article for some publication about his experiences in Afghanistan mid-deployment. He presented the article to me to review it and I was stunned that the piece was so anodyne. We were having our faces pressed into the stark realities of this deployment hourly and so I was disappointed in the characterization. But, I figured he was just trying to please his father, and I let it go―but in some ways I regret not ripping into him. We were both fine with intellectually rigorous debate and, indeed, that was probably one of the top things we liked about each other. (Maybe the piece got the requisite polite applause on the Ivy-league lecture tour—I don’t know.)
He knew about my background also: raised in a public housing project, public High School and eventually going to a State college. But, none of this mattered, as being ‘war buddies’ transcends all things. You’ve all seen it in the movies.
Many months after the deployment, I learned (I think from a text chain I was on) that he and his wife were going to be traveling from Connecticut to visit his family’s hunting lodge in Vermont, or Maine or something. To my delight I could see on a map that his route must be going right by my house! I’m talking not two minutes off of the highway. Geographically, it was a crazy lucky coincidence. I texted him about a visit as I wanted to meet his wife and he could meet my family. I had a wonderful two-year old adorable girl and my boy was born while I was on the deployment-he knew about it-and I was especially happy to show off my girl and new little infant boy. Wow! I was thrilled.
Well, I had trouble getting a response from this text. Crickets. I was sure there was a technical issue and persisted with emails and actual phone call messages until he responded-and I mean days later-and agreed. At the time, I still didn’t suspect anything and so had our tiny house (much smaller than the hunting lodge-I’d seen pictures) ready with fine drinks and snacks, etc.
Here they came. He and his wife sat on our couch as if they were in a Dentist’s waiting room. There was some empty strained conversation and then, oh! look at the time!
Wow. My wife said later that each of them were dressed, head to foot, in the best and most expensive clothing possible and, believe me, my wife knows about nice things. I guess we’d have to remortgage our house to buy the sweater that his wife was wearing. And I’ll never own the car they drove.
I wondered what those conversations were like between him and his wife after my invitation and before he finally, and reluctantly, responded. I’d like to hear the exact words.
I was heartsick, and embarrassed that I’d had no clue. We were such good friends and so alike in every way.
Well, every way but one.
And, I guess. . .
that one thing—
it mattered.

HESCO Barrier
Hi Kevin. I always read your posts and find them quite interesting. Could have been his wife that did not want to make the detour on the way to Vermont. – Love, Aunt Loretta
LikeLike
Hi Loretta- thanks for your support! I wish it were what you say-that’s forgivable-but no, it was a class thing all the way…I was naive to think our friendship would survive the return…
LikeLike
This blog entry was painful to read, and surely painful to write. Unfortunately your experience was not uncommon, I think, especially in the context of military service or schools. Loretta might well be right about the primary problem. The good news here is that when they quickly drove off, he took the full potential load of remorse with him. You have sadness, a sense of loss, and a sense of betrayal, I imagine, but you did nothing to feel remorseful about. He might in the future laboriously carry heavy gym plate-weights of remorse and shame up repeated daydream or insomnia Hesco barriers now and then for the rest of his life, but you won’t have to. You did the right thing. What matters? What mattered to him was class, not as achieved but as one is born into. What matters to you, obviously, are personal virtues that require real effort on our part to achieve and maintain: loyalty, decency, and honesty. I guess that one of the reasons those virtues require effort to maintain is because we meet a lot of people who lack them.
LikeLike
Hi Stephen- always good to hear from you and thanks again for another thoughtful and generous analysis . . . yes, I guess there may be elements of what both you and Loretta have said at play here. It’s funny, I was on a run the other day thinking about that incident and couldn’t shake it and the next day woke up and just banged it out. I guess in the end my level of naivete was also at play . . . I was half-thinking that they’d want to stay overnight even–given that they were on a vacation anyway. Maybe I also just fell for the old trap of expecting others to think and feel like oneself . . . You know, I really am lucky in the ways that you mention above; I’m lucky for that and to have you as such a longtime and sincere friend.
LikeLike